The Most Controversial Article So Far

Yosief Gberihwot is one of the talented bloger’s in Asmarino.com’s Hidmo Wufyat. His analysis focus in critics and usually are based on grounds of logic. However, in his recent article- Romanticizing Ghedli- he has gone too far, too controversial and too provocative. Provocative writing is good, in the sense forces society to see many questions from other angle. In this article, although there are some truth to some of his arguments, there are are wild and un reasonable arguments. Yosief went too far questioning every thing Eritrea has and tried to destroy the pride of Eritreans. He questioned the wisdom of our socity, the existence of Eritrean identity and the scarifies of our martyrs. Here is the full article to judge for your self.
http://zete9.asmarino.com/?itemid=1310

.....................................................................................
As expected, the above mentioned article have got some response and I hope more response will come responding to the points raised in Yosief's article. For the record and reference, I will post all the responses that came in the order of their publication.
...........
1. The First reponse is by Amanuel Eyasu, who presented a very strong response for many of the points. Here is the link to his article.
http://asena-online.com/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=725&Itemid=104

2. The Second response was from Amanuel Hidrat. This article is a reply to a particular point of the many points Yosief has made. Yosief has questioned the existence of Eritrean Identity and nationality. Amanuel Hidrat's response is specifically targed to that point. The link to his article is here:
http://zete9.asmarino.com/?itemid=1326

3. Yosief G has now provided another explanation for his article. In this explanation, " Identity through equality by subtraction", Yosief says the myths of Eritrean identity he refered in his first article refers to the identity developed in Gedli era. here is his full article:
http://zete9.asmarino.com/?itemid=1332

4. The third response " In defence of Gedli" comes from Habtom Yohanes. Habtom promises to provide case by case response to Y. G's article and to disproof Y.G. Part one of his response is here:
http://zete9.asmarino.com/?itemid=1341

5. Another response comes from Awate's page....and indication that the discusion has expanded to other websites. in this article, "Eritrean identity: My Amicus Curie " , Simon A. Woldehaimanot provides a littreture review of studies regarding Eritrean National Identity. here is his full article:
http://www.awate.com/portal/content/view/4810/5/

6. Merhawi Mesghina: provide a brief summary of the development of Eritrean identity into what seems another response to Yosief. His article: A Cursory and Partial Historical Account on Eritrea as an Entity of Collective Identity , can be accessed in the following link.
http://zete9.asmarino.com/?itemid=1360

7. Y.G provided the second part of his article: Romanizing Gedli II and he indicated part 3 will continue. Here is the link for part two.
http://zete9.asmarino.com/?itemid=1365

8.Habtom Yohanes presented part two of his article: In Defence of Gedli II. Here is the link:
http://zete9.asmarino.com/index.php?itemid=1352

9. Habtom Yohanes again presented part three of his "In Defence of Gedli III" article.
http://zete9.asmarino.com/index.php?itemid=1375

10. Y.G's part three of Romanizing Gedli:
http://zete9.asmarino.com/index.php?itemid=1400

11. Y.G. came with an extention of his series article: this one focusing on the Orthodox church and the Tigrigna Ethnic group.
http://zete9.asmarino.com/index.php?itemid=1429

12. The discusion is now joined by Petros Batay in Assenai.com. Petros has promised to provide a series of article in response to Y.G's article. Petros told Y.G. Don’t agonize organize. Here is the first part of his article:
http://asena-online.com/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=775&Itemid=207

13. Petros Batay's part two of " Don't agonize Organize" series is here:
http://asena-online.com/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=809&Itemid=207

DISTRUCTIONS AND RESPONSES:
while the discussions generated by by Y.G articles and the responses are mainly focusing on issues, Fessehaye Woldu came on awate.com with a rude and arrogant evaluation of the blogers and the discussion. His article came shortly under critisim from one of the bloger's in Asmarino.com.
14. Here is Fessehaye Woldu's article from awate.com:
http://www.awate.com/portal/content/view/4844/12/

15. And here is the response: Criticism or Personal Attack! a response to Fessehaye Woldu's article:
http://zete9.asmarino.com/?itemid=1439

and the discusion seems will continue......Y.G. deserves for generating this discusion.